top of page

OPINION: The Bay Area vs. Ohio: Transportation Freedom vs. Transportation Desert

An All Aboard Ohio member provides an interesting comparison between the Bay Area and Ohio's transportation infrastructure, focused on trains.

An All Aboard Ohio member provides an interesting comparison between the Bay Area and Ohio's transportation infrastructure, focused on trains.

January 15, 2026

Ed D'Amato

I’m a native Ohioan. I lived in the Buckeye State for 57 years but recently moved from Greater Cleveland to the San Francisco Bay Area because my wife took a job here. It has been an interesting change in many ways. Like any place, California has its good and bad points, but one of the good points, especially in the Bay Area, is the quality of transportation system. 


Northbound Caltrain and Southbound Amtrak Capitol Corridor Train meet at Santa Clara Station, Santa Clara, CA. August 2025.
Northbound Caltrain and Southbound Amtrak Capitol Corridor Train meet at Santa Clara Station, Santa Clara, CA. August 2025.

Like the rest of the U.S., California is dominated by car-centric sprawl, but it is still far ahead of Ohio when it comes to transportation freedom. Back in Ohio, we needed a car for almost everything. Here in the Bay Area, we hardly drive at all—only about twice per week. 


Here’s what it’s like for us now. Our town is located on the Caltrain line between San Jose and San Francisco. We could drive to the station but almost never do. We can walk there in about 15 minutes. The station is also the hub for the local bus network. About a block from our condo, we can also catch a bus that goes to San Jose International Airport, stopping at the Caltrain station along the way. 


Valley Transit Authority bus to San Jose International Airport gets ready to depart at Santa Clara Station as the southbound Caltrain to San Jose arrives. Note the bicycle locker next to the bus. (August 2025).
Valley Transit Authority bus to San Jose International Airport gets ready to depart at Santa Clara Station as the southbound Caltrain to San Jose arrives. Note the bicycle locker next to the bus. (August 2025).

Fourty-four Caltrain trains serve our station each weekday and 32 each weekend

day. There are also 14 daily Amtrak Capitol Corridor trains (San Jose-Sacramento), and eight Altamont Commuter Express trains per weekday (San Jose-Stockton). 


In San Jose, which is just a short bus or train ride away from us, we can catch local Amtrak’s Coast Starlight train between LA and Seattle (and during daylight hours, unlike Amtrak in Ohio), a local light rail line, city buses, a few Amtrak Thruway buses serve this station too, and eventually, California High Speed Rail trains as well.



Costco next to Lawrence Caltrain Station, Sunnyvale, California (August 2025).
Costco next to Lawrence Caltrain Station, Sunnyvale, California (August 2025).

Every train station out here is a multimodal hub served by local buses and, in some cases, local light rail. Each Caltrain has a car dedicated to bicycle storage, and many stations offer bike lockers. Several nearby communities along the Caltrain line have pedestrian-friendly development within a short walk of their station, making it possible to access shops and restaurants without driving. One stop even has a Costco adjacent to it. I sometimes shop there. 


Northbound Altamont Commuter Express stops at Santa Clara Station, Santa Clara, CA (August 2025)
Northbound Altamont Commuter Express stops at Santa Clara Station, Santa Clara, CA (August 2025)

We were back in Ohio for a week-long visit recently. The contrast was stark.

Suddenly, we had to adjust to driving almost everywhere. We had to discuss who needed the car and when. We had to plan most of what we did around driving. We drove more miles in a week back in Ohio than we do in a month out here in the Bay Area, and I was less relaxed because of that. Driving is a stressful activity, whether we consciously realize it or not. Since we have been out here and driving so much less, that stress is a lot more noticeable now when I do drive.



Amtrak’s northbound Coast Starlight pulling into San Jose Diridon Station (August 2025).
Amtrak’s northbound Coast Starlight pulling into San Jose Diridon Station (August 2025).

It is absolutely liberating to only drive when we want to or need to rather than having to because there is no other choice—and we’ve gotten used to it quickly. Here’s a funny story:  One evening this past summer, I needed to get to the train station to go somewhere. I misjudged the time and realized, I wouldn’t be able to walk there or get the bus in time to catch my train, so my wife and I started discussing our options, including hailing a Lyft. We had completely forgotten that we own a car, and my wife could just drop me at the station. We had a good laugh about it, but it is a good example of how our perspective on transportation has changed since we moved here. 


Passengers alighting/boarding northbound Caltrain, Mountain View California (October 2025)
Passengers alighting/boarding northbound Caltrain, Mountain View California (October 2025)

Support Us

We're the largest passenger rail and transit advocate in Ohio. Help us make a difference in the Midwest.

ConnectedPoster - 9.jpg

Ed D'Amato

Guest Writer: Long-time Ohioan who moved to California

Our Mission

We advocate for better transit and passenger rail throughout the Midwest. Your support helps us.

The Streamline Transit Act cuts federal red tape, allowing Ohio to fast-track rail NEPA reviews like highways. This could save years and millions on projects like a Cincinnati, Columbus, Dayton, Cleveland rail corridor.

News Story

Passenger Rail Projects Could Speed Along Under New Bipartisan Bill

St. Louis must spend $1.4 million to modify new trains that are too tall for their tunnels, but Cleveland cannot acquire these units due to critical voltage and door incompatibilities. Despite sharing the Siemens S200 model name, the fleets are mechanically unique, validating GCRTA's decision to custom-engineer its own vehicles rather than relying on shared designs.

AAO Blog Post

"Wrong" Trains are the Same Model as Cleveland. Measurement Mistakes in St. Louis

Make a huge impact on our 2026 initiatives by donating to our $5,000 goal this Giving Tuesday 12/2. In 2025 we accomplished a lot, track what we did by month, thanks to donor impact and passenger rail advocates in Ohio.

AAO Blog Post

Donor Impact Across Ohio: How AAO Delivered in 2025

In December the Federal Railroad Administration announced updates to the Corridor ID program. These updates tailor next steps of the program towards the complexity of projects to smooth the ability to receive approvals and confidence from the federal government. This impacts routes in Ohio like those through Columbus, Cleveland, Cincinnati, and Toledo.

Featured Post

Big Changes to Federal Passenger Rail Funding Program - The Impact

ABOUT ALL ABOARD OHIO
All Aboard Ohio is a non-profit, member-based organization dedicated to promoting improved public transportation and passenger rail service throughout the state. 

Founded in 1973 and incorporated as a registered 501c-3 in 1987, All Aboard Ohio has spent more than 50 years advocating, educating, and working towards our goal of a connected Midwest

All Aboard Ohio is a 501c-3 nonprofit with over 50 years of advocacy work, advocating for improved public transportation and passenger rail service in the Midwest

©2025 by All Aboard Ohio

Get in Touch

Contact us form

info@allaboardohio.org

3136 Kingsdale Center, 


#112 Columbus, OH 43221

Federal Tax ID: 31-1066182

  • Facebook
  • X
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Threads

All Aboard Ohio is a 501c-3 nonprofit with over 50 years of advocacy work, advocating for improved public transportation and passenger rail service in the Midwest

©2025 by All Aboard Ohio

Get in Touch

Contact us form

info@allaboardohio.org

3136 Kingsdale Center, 


#112 Columbus, OH 43221

Federal Tax ID: 31-1066182

  • Instagram
  • Bluesky
  • Threads
  • Youtube
  • Facebook
  • X
  • LinkedIn
bottom of page