top of page

Ohio's Goldilocks Moment: Why Failed Rail Projects Elsewhere Put Ohio in the Driver's Seat

From Boondoggles to Breakthroughs: Ohio’s Passenger Train Strategy Is Federally Favorable

From Boondoggles to Breakthroughs: Ohio’s Passenger Train Strategy Is Federally Favorable

August 13, 2025

Ryan Pecaut

You’ve probably seen the headlines about high-profile passenger rail projects in states like California and Texas going off the rails, losing billions in federal funding. It’s easy to look at that news and feel discouraged about the future of trains in America.


But what if we told you that was actually good news for Ohio?


It’s true. The failure of those speculative, hyper-expensive projects has caused a massive shift in federal policy. The government isn't backing away from rail; it's stated it's getting smarter. It's pivoting away from risky "moonshots" and looking for practical, fiscally responsible, and deliverable projects.


In other words, the federal government is looking for projects just like Ohio's. This is the buckeye state's moment to seize a historic opportunity and build a modern passenger rail network for the 21st century.


The Feds Have a New Playbook


The Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) has learned some very expensive lessons. After seeing projects like California's spiral from a $33 billion estimate to a mind-boggling $135 billion, they've developed a new, unwritten policy we can call the "Viability Doctrine."


Gone are the days of blank checks for aspirational visions. The new federal playbook prioritizes projects that are:

  • Fiscally Realistic: No more runaway budgets. The numbers have to be credible and based on sound engineering.

  • Built on Existing Infrastructure: Using existing rail corridors dramatically cuts costs, timelines, and environmental hurdles.

  • Backed by Strong Local Support: The feds want to see a unified front from state and local governments, businesses, and community leaders.

  • Grounded and Deliverable: The goal is to get shovels in the ground and trains running, not to fund perpetual planning exercises.


This is where Ohio hits the jackpot. It's proposed corridors—the 3C+D (Cleveland-Columbus-Dayton-Cincinnati), the Midwest Connect (Chicago-Columbus-Pittsburgh), and the Cleveland-Toledo-Detroit link—are a perfect match for this new doctrine. By design, they are the responsible antidote to the "boondoggles" that failed elsewhere.


In fact, all three of Ohio's corridors have already been accepted into the FRA's Corridor ID program, a structured process designed to vet and develop successful projects. They aren't just knocking on the door; the federal government has already invited them in.


The Ohio Advantage: A Plan That's "Just Right"


Ohio's vision for passenger rail is the ultimate "Goldilocks" project. It's not a minor fix, but it deliberately avoids the massive costs and construction risks that doomed high-speed rail. By focusing on conventional-speed service on existing tracks, Ohio present's a low-risk, high-reward proposition.


Consider the contrast:

  • California's "Train to Nowhere": Plagued by mismanagement and a $100+ billion price tag.

  • Ohio's 3C+D Corridor: Connects the state's four largest economic hubs—including Columbus, the second-largest metro area in the US with no Amtrak service—for a tiny fraction of that cost, and generous economic benefits to the state.


Some might bring up the "ghost" of 2010, when a previous rail plan was cancelled. But we can turn that history into a strength. The current plan is a direct result of learning from the past. The powerful, bipartisan coalition of cities, chambers of commerce, and planning organizations Ohio has built shows that Ohio has done its homework and is now a more reliable and resilient partner for federal investment.


It's Time to Go All Aboard


The stars have aligned for Ohio. Federal policy has shifted in our favor. Billions of dollars from cancelled projects are being returned to grant programs for which the buckeye state is a prime candidate with it's practical, popular, and shovel-ready plan.


The national narrative of passenger rail failure is being rewritten. With a smart, strategic approach, Ohio won't just be a chapter in that story—it will be the headline.

Support Us

We're the largest passenger rail and transit advocate in Ohio. Help us make a difference in the Midwest.

ConnectedPoster - 9.jpg

Ryan Pecaut

Ryan Pecaut is the Communications Strategy Lead at All Aboard Ohio

Our Mission

We advocate for better transit and passenger rail throughout the Midwest. Your support helps us.

Cincinnati Amtrak riders can look forward to future daily train service as Amtrak has submitted step 1 of planning to the Federal Railroad Administration. Many steps still lie ahead before daily service, up from 3x/week, will start.

News Story

Amtrak Submits Step 1 of Daily Cardinal Planning to Federal Railroad Administration

A new report from the Chaddick Institute for Metropolitan Development details how Amtrak's Chicago hub is leading to continued growth of rail travel in the Midwest. It also details how under continued success seats are selling out and new rail coaches and routes are likely needed.

News Story

Chicago Hub: Report Details Model for Midwest Rail Renaissance

The City of Cincinnati requests official proposals for development in the space that was supposed to be a Cincinnati subway.

News Story

Public Transit an Official Option as Cincinnati Seeks Proposals for Historic Subway Tunnels

Access Ohio 2050, the state’s long-range transportation plan, is beginning its second round of public feedback sessions and community members are invited to participate. Results so far show passenger rail is a priority for Ohioans, especially young ones, and as planning progresses advocates will continue to need to push to ensure plans include passenger rail.

Featured Post

GET INVOLVED: Ohio Gathering Feedback to Shape 2050 Transport Plans

ABOUT ALL ABOARD OHIO
All Aboard Ohio is a non-profit, member-based organization dedicated to promoting improved public transportation and passenger rail service throughout the state. 

Founded in 1973 and incorporated as a registered 501c-3 in 1987, All Aboard Ohio has spent more than 50 years advocating, educating, and working towards our goal of a connected Midwest

All Aboard Ohio is a 501c-3 nonprofit with over 50 years of advocacy work, advocating for improved public transportation and passenger rail service in the Midwest

©2025 by All Aboard Ohio

Get in Touch

Contact us form

info@allaboardohio.org

3136 Kingsdale Center, 


#112 Columbus, OH 43221

Federal Tax ID: 31-1066182

  • Facebook
  • X
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Threads

All Aboard Ohio is a 501c-3 nonprofit with over 50 years of advocacy work, advocating for improved public transportation and passenger rail service in the Midwest

Cleveland Tower Photo by cmh2315fl on Flickr (CC)

©2025 by All Aboard Ohio

Get in Touch

Contact us form

info@allaboardohio.org

3136 Kingsdale Center, 


#112 Columbus, OH 43221

Federal Tax ID: 31-1066182

  • Instagram
  • Bluesky
  • Threads
  • Youtube
  • Facebook
  • X
  • LinkedIn
bottom of page