top of page

Scrapping Rail Projects Doesn’t Just Waste Money—It Strands Lives

Passenger rail is my lifeline—it connects me to my children, grandchildren, and great-grandchildren. I can’t fly and I can barely drive. Without reliable trains, I’m stranded.

Passenger rail is my lifeline—it connects me to my children, grandchildren, and great-grandchildren. I can’t fly and I can barely drive. Without reliable trains, I’m stranded.

July 28, 2025

Marilyn Sheck

Passenger rail is a lifeline for me.  It is my connection to my children, grandchildren and great grandchildren.  I cannot fly.  I have crippling anxiety, acrophobia, and get debilitating vertigo if I fly.  Train travel lets me relax and enjoy my trip.  It enables me to visit my family members.  


My husband retired in 2008 after he was diagnosed with Cancer.  That diagnosis made us look into when I might be able to retire.  We found out that I would be eligible for early retirement on July 7, 2009.  We started planning.  Where would we live?  Seattle was much too expensive to stay there.  We had lived in Florida for 11 years and did not want to go back there.  Between us we had 4 adult children, who lived in Toledo, Beavercreek, Pittsburgh and Phoenix.  Our research told us that Ohio was about to start their 3C rail project.  When it was completed it would be our pathway to all our offspring.  We decided to move to the Toledo area, and bought a condo in Sylvania.  We figured we would still able to drive while the rail line was being constructed.  It would be finished just when we would no longer have driving as an option.  Perfect!  But then Governor Kasich decided to return the $400 million to the feds and scrap the 3C.  We felt like victims of bait and switch.  Here we were stuck in a place that would keep us from visiting our loved ones within 10 years.  


My husband died in Fall 2021.  When he became ill, we moved to Beavercreek to be near my son.  He knew I would need help with caring for my husband.  I still live in Beavercreek.  I still can drive, but not on Interstates and not more than a couple of hours at a time.  My 2016 Jeep Cherokee sits in my garage 99% of the time.  I use it to get groceries or go to doctor appointments.  I drive to Columbus once a year for the All Aboard Ohio annual meeting.  It has just over 29,000 miles on it. Public transit in my area is not an option.  I have become more or less a prisoner in my own home.  Last February I traveled to my granddaughter's wedding in Gilbert, Arizona.  My son drove me to Cincinnati the afternoon before my train was due to leave.  I had to stay in a hotel until midnight, then get a taxi to the train station for a 1:41 AM departure.  Fortunately, I had found a taxi driver who was always willing to be my transportation.  That is not as easy as you might think.  Taxi companies and ride-share companies are willing to take a reservation, but they cannot guarantee that a driver will pick up the reservation.  I need a guaranteed ride in order to get to the station on time.  After boarding the train in the middle of the night I just slept until it was nearly time to reach Chicago.  When I reached Chicago, I had to get a taxi to a hotel, where I had to spend another night.  The Amtrak Cardinal, which serves Cincinnati, only runs 3 days a week.  The Amtrak Texas Eagle, which gets me to Maricopa, Arizona, also runs only 3 days a week.  BUT THEY ARE NOT THE SAME THREE DAYS.  So, even though I arrived in Chicago at 10 AM, and my connecting train leaves in the evening, I had to spend a night in Chicago and sit in the Metropolitan Lounge most of the next day waiting to board.  


Photo of lady in an office sitting on chair - chest to just over head - newspaper clippings visible in the background

Spending two nights in hotels before ever leaving the Midwest added at least $500 to the cost of my trip.  If the Cardinal and Texas Eagle both ran daily I would only have to spend one night, in Cincinnati.  When the 3C&D line is built, and if the Cardinal and Texas Eagle go to daily service, no nights in hotels would be necessary.   Unfortunately, I will most likely not be able to take advantage of that line because I will be close to 90 years old, if I'm lucky enough to live that long, and most likely won't be traveling any more.


I fear that Ohio will decide to pass on the 3C&D, just as they did on the 3C.  If that happens, I feel I have only one choice.  My grandchildren are about to start their freshman and junior years in high school.  In four years, when they will both be in college, I will move to a state that has good public transit and has an Amtrak station.  My son and his wife will also move.  I am sure that I am not the only one who will make the decision to move away from here rather than spend their last years unable to drive and with no other options.  And I am equally sure that young people will choose to live in states with good transit and easy rail access.  My 6 grandchildren range in age from 14 to 34.  They all would rather not drive if they had options.  Not proceeding with the 3C&D would be a HUGE mistake for Ohio's future.  Ohio could become the crossroads of America if the projects currently being planned are allowed to come to fruition.


Support Us

We're the largest passenger rail and transit advocate in Ohio. Help us make a difference in the Midwest.

ConnectedPoster - 9.jpg

Marilyn Sheck

Marilyn is a grandmother in Beavercreek OH who moved to Ohio when passenger rail was announced

Our Mission

We advocate for better transit and passenger rail throughout the Midwest. Your support helps us.

Ohio’s rural communities are innovating to overcome transportation barriers—this is how local partnerships, citizen advocacy, and flexible transit models are reshaping mobility and resilience across the Buckeye State

AAO Blog Post

Building Resilient Transporation Everywhere Is Possible: The Buckeye State Deserves Better Part II

From Boondoggles to Breakthroughs: Ohio’s Passenger Train Strategy Is Federally Favorable

AAO Blog Post

Ohio's Goldilocks Moment: Why Failed Rail Projects Elsewhere Put Ohio in the Driver's Seat

From predawn departures to Midwest rail visions — All Aboard Ohio’s “Race to Chicago” shows why better Amtrak service can connect Ohio’s cities, boost communities, and power a more connected Midwest.

AAO Blog Post

How Rail Fans Raced on Amtrak from Ohio to Chicago

A $200 billion federal bill could finally expand modern passenger rail across the nation. But major hurdles stand in the way of this transformative funding project for Passenger Rail

Featured Post

New "All Aboard Act" Could Funnel Billions into Ohio Passenger Rail, But Major Hurdles Remain

ABOUT ALL ABOARD OHIO
All Aboard Ohio is a non-profit, member-based organization dedicated to promoting improved public transportation and passenger rail service throughout the state. 

Founded in 1973 and incorporated as a registered 501c-3 in 1987, All Aboard Ohio has spent more than 50 years advocating, educating, and working towards our goal of a connected Midwest

All Aboard Ohio is a 501c-3 nonprofit with over 50 years of advocacy work, advocating for improved public transportation and passenger rail service in the Midwest

©2025 by All Aboard Ohio

Get in Touch

Contact us form

info@allaboardohio.org

3136 Kingsdale Center, 


#112 Columbus, OH 43221

Federal Tax ID: 31-1066182

  • Facebook
  • X
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Threads

All Aboard Ohio is a 501c-3 nonprofit with over 50 years of advocacy work, advocating for improved public transportation and passenger rail service in the Midwest

Cleveland Tower Photo by cmh2315fl on Flickr (CC)

©2025 by All Aboard Ohio

Get in Touch

Contact us form

info@allaboardohio.org

3136 Kingsdale Center, 


#112 Columbus, OH 43221

Federal Tax ID: 31-1066182

  • Instagram
  • Bluesky
  • Threads
  • Youtube
  • Facebook
  • X
  • LinkedIn
bottom of page